Archive for March, 2010

And we’re done.The film has been burnt to DVD and is currently on it’s way to Schull where we hope to make it for this years Fastnet Film Festival again 🙂 . It’s really a beautiful spot in West Cork and definitely worth going to even if you don’t necessarily want to watch the first showing of Hardly Fairest, unfortunately this does mean that the film will not be made available online for quite some time or at least soon after it’s shown in Fastnet. Work has already begun on the next film, without giving too much away I would urge anyone who is interested in knowing what it’s about to … stay tuned. ( I’ll probably change this last bit if we change our mind on what we’re going to do next )

Back to Hardly Fairest, this was our first foray into shooting and editing high-definition footage, and it has been quiet the bumpy experience from a technical standpoint. First off since the original footage was recorded from a DSLR camera, I was working with different ergonomics in mind, I would use my thumb to record the footage while the other fingers gripped to the camera’s side, the other hand would either adjust the focus during the shoot or have the camera held securely since their were no straps to secure the camera with. A bit awkward to work with at first but shooting with a Tripod makes the process substantially easier and it’s easily a deterrent in shooting with handheld, I’m not a fan of doing the latter anyway so it’s no big deal for me.

On the Post Production side of things working with Cinelerra 4.1 didn’t quiet work out so well as I had hoped, although I came across some strange artefacting in the project monitor but when it came to rendering the footage this was where I ran into a problem. Turned out that rendering the footage produced a different set of artefacts in the first five seconds of the rendered footage, the B-Frames ( or maybe it was the P-Frames … ) seemed to have ended up becoming corrupted, creating some very ugly features in the rendered footage. Also on several occasions when I was cutting a few seconds off the video I found that the audio portion had a greater portion removed than the video track itself and causing some sync issues. It was too difficult to come to terms with Cinelerra’s shortcomings, so I switched to Kdenlive instead.

I dabbled with this tool several times in the past and have found it to be quite unforgiving whenever I came across a bug in which case caused several hours of work go to waste. But it’s seemed to have matured since, currently on version, it has quickly become one of my favourite NLE applications despite some of it’s limitations, few unwelcome crashes and some niggling issues but on a whole it looks and it works just great. In comparison to some of the other free NLE’s available on Linux, this one trounces them in terms of ease of use and handling of different file types.

Read Full Post »

Introducing a film that adds another entry in Cethan Leahy’s list of screenwriting and directing credits, Hardly Fairest was shot on the 14th of March with the newly purchased Canon 7D and is currently well under way in Post Production. So far it’s looking pretty good. It took at least 4 hours to shoot the film, those who have seen First A Dream may notice an air of familiarity in the location used for this film. We’re aiming to get the film fully edited before the 28th and have it submitted shortly before the deadline of this years Fastnet Film Festival located in Schull, West Cork. It’s not known when exactly we’re going to post the film online however, since we’re planning on submitting the film to other festivals in the coming few months we’re going to take into consideration that they might not be willing to accept it if it’s already available online.

Production methods used for this film have changed somewhat over the previous films, not only are we working with a new camera but with a new PC with specifications that will remain pretty decent for at least 6 months until some mobile phone gets introduced into the market that will trounce the new PC in terms of performance. The majority of the editing is now carried out by Kdenlive for the time being since the current versions of Cinelerra ( 2.1 and 4.1 ) are proving to be quiet unreliable when working with the 7D footage. Also props created from scratch by Cethan were used in the making of this film and they look great, hopefully this will start some sort of trend in future productions.

Read Full Post »

I love working with Cinelerra, I really do, but sometimes I find myself having to make a few compromises when it comes to getting it to work seamlessly with newly recorded footage. Normally I would have to convert the original video to a format that Cinelerra can edit. From the various cameras I’ve worked with, the original footage has already been compressed, converting it to another format before editing it is unpleasant because it can degrade the quality further.

Canon 7D uses the .MOV container format to hold a h264 encoded video and a 2 channel pcm_s16le encoded audio track together. Works fine when you play it with VLC or run it through some Transcoding tools like Avidemux. With Cinelerra though, it’s somewhat problematic. Although you can import the video file just fine and run it through the timeline, Cinelerra is unable to play the audio portion of the file. Cinelerra is able to read h264 encoded videos separately just fine , likewise for pcm_s15le encoded audio but the problem lies with the container format. Run it through ffmpeg and you’ll get a message like this:

“Seems stream 0 codec frame rate differs from container frame rate: 50000.00 (50000/1) -> 25.00 (25/1)”

At the moment Cinelerra 4.1 only decides to work with the video stream and ignores the audio stream, normally in this case I would extract the audio portion of the file, import it separately into the project and manually attach it to the video file in the timeline but that’s far too tedious to make it worthwhile. Instead, repackaging the file into another container will do the trick. My choice is the Maktroska format, an open source container format similar to MOV, AVI or MP4 but much more flexible in terms of how much media content it can hold and what codecs it supports. You can read more about the format from this Wikipedia article. The important thing to note is that Cinelerra 4.1 does support it.

Canon 7D .mov footage with no playable audio

Changing the container takes only a few seconds with very negligible difference in the size of the original video file and the recently produced MKV file. Most importantly the audio and video content remains untouched. The quickest way of changing the container is through the command line using ffmpeg as the transcoding tool, this command will do the trick:

“ffmpeg -i mvi_8927.mov -vcodec copy -acodec copy mvi_8927.mkv”

Explanation: So here the “mvi_8947.mov” is used as the input file, the video codec ( vcodec ) is to set to copy the input instead of converting to another format, same goes for the audio codec ( acodec ) and finally “mvi_8947.mkv” is the file output with the Matroska video extension. Ffmpeg then goes ahead copies the audio and video portions into a Maktroska file which you can then import into Cinelerra 4.1 . Now we’re able to work with Canon 7D files with both audio and video portions made playable in Cinelerra.

Canon 7D footage repackaged into MKV format, now with audio and weird artefacts in the video preview

But it’s not without its oddities, version of Cinelerra 4.1 has some artefacting issues in the Compositor when the video is paused. Despite this, the artefacting never shows up when played or rendered in Cinelerra. It’s nothing to be too worried about.

Note: This tutorial won’t work with community version of Cinelerra, for the time being Cinelerra 2.1 ( 22nd February 2010 build version ) is unable to read MKV properly for me.

Read Full Post »

Finally procured the Canon 7D. After watching some fantastic footage on Philip Bloom’s website and countless other examples on Youtube, actually I was pretty much sold on the idea of using DSLR cameras to shoot films with since watching REVERIE on Canon’s website, although this showcases the 5D Mark II, the technical differences between this camera and the 7D are merely subtle with the exception of considerably larger sensor size ( 35mm vs 22mm ) and a heftier price tag ( aprox €1,000 more ). With the 7D, it’s now a lot easier to transfer films from the camera straight to the editing equipment since it takes is a memory card reader and a few seconds to transfer. Being able to change the lens is also a great bonus since it allows for pretty flexible filming styles. More importantly the camera works fantastically well in low light conditions.

Despite my praises the camera still has its shortcomings, first off it’s a lot more uncomfortable to shoot with since the ergonomics weren’t designed for handheld shooting in mind. The CMOS sensor is subjected to the Rolling Shutter effect when it comes to sudden movements such as quick panning effects, although fixable through editing tools like Virtualdub when used with Deshaker for example, it’s still going to add a layer of tediousness to some footage that features a lot of motion. Canon 7D is also limited to a recording filesize of 4 GB and it doesn’t even bother rolling back to a new file once the limit has been reached. According to some articles on the web, some users experienced overheating during the video recording although this seems likely to happen when shooting at lower resolutions according to this blog post.

Here’s some early test footage ( shrunk down to 540P and then heavily compressed by Vimeo )

It takes nice images too.

Read Full Post »